Leave Management Tool vs. Manual Tracking: Which Saves More Time and Money?
Employees need to take time off, too. But while managing employee leaves the traditional way or through spreadsheets and paper forms might be familiar, it can negatively impact your business’s efficiency and costs. Leave management software could be what you need; it streamlines everything without the usual issues. It takes the hassle out of handling employee time off. Tracking time off matters because mismanagement could reduce productivity, compliance issues, and dissatisfied employees.
Which option saves your business more time and money? Find out by reading more.
What Is a Leave Management Tool?
Leave management software simplifies how businesses handle time off requests. The key features include:
Automated Leave Requests and Approvals
Employees submit requests digitally through a leave management tool, reducing manual paperwork and administrative delays. Managers don’t have to approve leaves in person or through emails if they can receive instant notifications and approve or deny a leave request with just a few clicks.
You can also automate time off accruals, making annual leave policies manageable and transparent. Doing so informs everyone on your team about their paid time off (PTO) entitlements.
Integrated Calendars
Visual scheduling tools show you who’s out without flipping through pages of physical notes, making it easier to manage workloads. These calendars often synchronize with existing systems like company-wide schedules or project management platforms, providing a clear view of team availability and helping prevent scheduling conflicts.
Reporting and Analytics
These features help you analyze leave patterns and forecast staffing needs. Detailed reports track absenteeism trends, leave balances, and peak time off periods, allowing you to make better decisions about resource allocation and future hiring.
Compliance Tracking
Built-in features help ensure your business follows labor laws and company policies. Automated alerts remind you of upcoming deadlines for legally required leave types, and the system maintains accurate records for audits or disputes.
Consider using a free HR system that includes these features, including others such as hiring and onboarding, asset management, and employee performance. Together, these capabilities decrease repetitive tasks and provide insights that improve planning. They also let HR staff focus on more strategic initiatives rather than spending time manually managing time off requests and reconciliations.
The Challenges of Manual Tracking
Manual tracking worked well enough in the past, but running a business in today’s digital world brings new challenges.
Errors, Inefficiencies, and Time Consumption
Manual data entry requires constant cross-referencing, making it prone to mistakes. Paper forms could get lost, spreadsheets might introduce errors, and reconciling records with payroll takes excessive time. Approving leave also becomes more complicated when multiple employees submit requests simultaneously, especially during peak vacation seasons.
Data Security
Manual tracking methods present significant security risks. Physical forms and spreadsheets lack built-in safeguards to prevent unauthorized access or data tampering. When personal leave details are written down on paper, they’re at risk of being lost, damaged, or seen by the wrong people. Plus, good luck finding specific records when you need them for audits.
In contrast, leave management tools often include encryption, role-based access, and automated backups utilizing best cybersecurity practices. Modern features keep sensitive information under lock and key while meeting compliance requirements.
Impact on Employee Satisfaction and Productivity
Paid leave is one of the major factors when choosing a job among 71% of Gen Z workers. Time off directly affects your team’s paychecks, so keeping accurate records should also be a priority. (1)
Making mistakes frustrates employees when their leave balances are incorrect, or approvals are delayed. When employees start doubting the system, their motivation takes a hit, and before you know it, they’re updating their resumes. Clean, accurate leave tracking keeps everyone happy and focused on their work.
It can be difficult to transition from manual tracking to a leave management tool. But once you fully integrate the system into your HR processes, you’ll see how easy it is to approve and track employee leaves.
Comparing Time and Cost Efficiency
Organizations that switch from a manual time off tracking system to an automated leave management solution often report dramatic time savings. If you still require employees to email their leave requests, you could waste around 3.4 hours a week or 177 hours per year reading them when you could focus on crucial tasks. (2)
Several automated tools for leave management may also have artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities. Research shows that AI-powered HR systems effectively handle leave management alongside other functions like productivity tracking and payroll. Processing leave requests, updating records, and integrating data with payroll become significantly faster, cutting costs on labor and error corrections. (3)
Manual tracking struggles to scale as businesses grow. More employees mean more leave requests, approvals, and potential mistakes. Leave management tools expand with less effort, handling higher volumes without added workload. Over time, automated systems lower costs, reduce legal risks, and improve the employee experience.
Which Option Is Best for Your Business?
Each leave tracking option has its pros and cons. But one may be better than the other, depending on the size of your company. So, it boils down to how many people you’re managing.
Small businesses might lean toward manual tracking because it appears cost-effective initially. However, as leave complexity grows, the inefficiencies outweigh the savings.
On the other hand, given the volume of requests and regulatory requirements, larger companies might see immediate benefits from automation. Ninety-five percent of respondents from one study even reveal that a leave management system is more convenient, and 98% agree that it delivers timely service. However, you might need to pay a monthly fee to use the tool and all its features. (4)
Assess your needs by evaluating how frequently employees take leave, the number of leave types, and how integrated your HR processes are. A leave management tool offers a more scalable solution if manual tracking consumes too much time or leads to frequent errors.
Final Thoughts: Making the Switch
Switching to a leave management tool transforms how you handle time off requests. Automation reduces administrative work while maintaining accuracy as your business grows.
Compare your current process against modern leave management tools to see potential improvements. The right solution can save you hours of administrative work each week, cut down on costly mistakes, and give your employees one less thing to worry about.
References
- “How Companies Can Improve Paid Leave with New ‘Leading on Leave Index’,” Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michelletravis/2024/10/13/how-companies-can-improve-paid-leave-with-new-leading-on-leave-index/
- “7 Biggest Workplace Time Wasters and How to Handle Them,” Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikekappel/2022/06/15/7-biggest-workplace-time-wasters-and-how-to-handle-them/
- “A study of Artificial Intelligence impacts on Human Resource Digitalization in Industry 4.0,” Source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2772662223000899
- “EMPLOYEE LEAVE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM,” Source: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342815048_EMPLOYEE_LEAVE_MANAGEMENT_SYSTEM